Fake It Till You Make It: Does It Work, and When Does It Backfire?

Last updated on October 3rd, 2026 at 09:25 am

On her first day leading a team, a Des Moines nurse felt like an impostor. She borrowed her mentor’s calm, and by month three it felt like hers.

Fake it till you make it is the advice to act confident, capable, or calm before you feel that way, trusting that the feeling will follow.

The Des Moines nurse did not pretend to have skills she lacked; she borrowed a demeanor while she built real competence.

Research suggests acting a certain way can change how you feel and how others respond, but faking skills or credentials can backfire badly.

The sections below explain where the phrase comes from, what studies show, when it helps, when it harms, and how to use it honestly.

Where the Phrase Comes From

The phrase is closely associated with recovery communities such as Alcoholics Anonymous, where members were encouraged to “act as if” they could stay sober before they fully believed it.

Philosopher William James made a similar point in the 1880s, arguing that acting cheerful could help produce cheerfulness.

Social psychologist Amy Cuddy later reframed it in a widely viewed 2012 talk as “fake it till you become it.”

What It Means and What It Doesn’t

Healthy VersionUnhealthy Version
Acting confident while building real skillsClaiming skills or credentials you lack
Borrowing calm body language under stressHiding serious struggles or illness
Trying new behaviors to growPretending to be someone you are not for years
Speaking up despite nervesBluffing in high-stakes situations where errors cause harm

What Research Shows

Research by William Fleeson and colleagues found that when people acted more extraverted in daily life, they reported more positive emotion, even if they were naturally introverted.

A 2019 study by Rowan Jacques-Hamilton, Jessie Sun, and Luke Smillie asked people to act extraverted for a week and found positive emotion rose on average.

However, the most introverted participants did not share those benefits and reported some costs, such as more fatigue and negative emotion.

Research on power poses adds a caution: early claims that expansive postures change hormones did not replicate.

People may still feel slightly more confident, as discussed in power poses and confidence.

Why Acting Confident Can Work

  • Self-perception: Psychologist Daryl Bem proposed that people infer their own attitudes partly by observing their behavior, so acting confident can shift how you see yourself, an idea explored in how self-perception works.
  • Mastery experiences: Acting before you feel ready creates chances to succeed, which build genuine confidence, as explained in the roots of self-confidence.
  • Others’ responses: People respond to confident behavior with more trust and opportunity, which reinforces confidence.
  • Breaking avoidance: Acting despite fear prevents avoidance from strengthening anxiety.

When Fake It Till You Make It Backfires

Faking Competence

Claiming skills you do not have can lead to dangerous mistakes, especially in medicine, engineering, finance, or law.

High-profile fraud cases show how faking results, rather than confidence, can destroy careers and harm others.

Ignoring Real Problems

Pretending to be fine while struggling with depression, burnout, or grief can delay needed help.

Losing Authenticity

Performing a personality that does not fit for years can be exhausting, especially for introverts, as the 2019 study suggests.

Fueling Impostor Feelings

If you never acknowledge your growing skills, faking can deepen the sense that you are a fraud.

Slipping Into Arrogance

Overplayed confidence can look like arrogance, a line explored in confidence that stays humble.

Fake Confidence vs Fake Competence

Fake ConfidenceFake Competence
What you’re doingActing calm and capable while learningClaiming abilities you lack
RiskLow; mostly to your comfortHigh; to others and your reputation
OutcomeReal confidence grows with practiceMistakes, lost trust, possible harm
Ethical?Yes, when honest about your skillsNo

How to Fake It Till You Make It the Right Way

Act Confident, Stay Honest

Carry yourself with calm while being truthful about what you know and what you are learning.

Build Real Skills at the Same Time

Pair confident behavior with study, practice, and feedback.

Borrow From Role Models

Watch how calm, capable people speak and move, and adopt habits that fit you.

Use Supportive Self-Talk

Replace “I’m a fraud” with “I’m learning, and I’m prepared,” using supportive self-talk methods.

Start With Small Stretches

Practice confident behavior in lower-stakes settings first, as described in stepping beyond your comfort zone.

Notice Your Progress

Track skills gained and challenges handled, so confidence rests on evidence.

Adapt to Your Personality

Introverts can act confident without acting loud; calm, prepared contributions count, as explored in introvert strengths at work.

Ask for Help When Needed

Admitting gaps to the right people is a sign of maturity, not weakness.

Fake It Till You Make It in Specific Situations

  • Job interviews: Speak with calm confidence about real experience; never invent qualifications.
  • New roles: Act decisively on what you know, and ask questions about what you do not.
  • Public speaking: Adopt steady posture and pacing even when nervous, as covered in confidence on stage.
  • Social situations: Introduce yourself and start conversations even when shy.

Deeper inner steadiness is explored in trusting yourself emotionally.

In my observation, the people who fake it well are not pretending to be someone else; they are acting as the more confident version of themselves they are already becoming.

Conclusion

The Des Moines nurse now trains new team leads, and she tells them to borrow calm while they build skill.

Fake it till you make it works when it means acting confident while honestly building real competence, and it backfires when it means faking skills or hiding real struggles.

Research shows that acting in new ways can lift mood and confidence, though benefits vary by personality.

This week, choose one situation where you usually hold back, act as the confident version of yourself, and note what happens.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does fake it till you make it mean?

It means acting confident or capable before you feel that way, trusting that real confidence will grow through action and experience.

Does fake it till you make it actually work?

Research suggests acting differently can change mood and self-perception, but it works best when paired with real skill-building and honesty.

When is faking it a bad idea?

It is a bad idea when it means claiming skills you lack, hiding serious struggles, or bluffing where mistakes could harm others.

Where does the phrase fake it till you make it come from?

It is closely associated with recovery communities such as Alcoholics Anonymous, which encouraged members to “act as if” before fully believing.